The mash up dj Girl Talk is a great example of this. He consistently uses bits and pieces from other artists' work. There is always a constant thought that the original creators of the songs he uses could come to him later asking for royalties which could turn into an exorbitant amount of money depending on the popularity of the artist or the song in general. Fair Use regulations would technically state that he can't use this music without having the right to.
Some would state that this could also be constituted as transformative use based on how much of a song he actually uses. Sometimes he may also use one little drum hit or a piece of a horn or something like that. Yes he did take these things from a copyrighted recording, but it may not really be enough to warrant reaction from the original artist.
All of these considerations make for a very controversial argument about Girl Talk's case. Hopefully, for the sake of his fan base, there won't be any prosecution of his work for copyrights. While his work isn't as relevant now as it used to be, he does have 5 albums out that haven't been touched. I suppose we will have to see in the future.
Some would state that this could also be constituted as transformative use based on how much of a song he actually uses. Sometimes he may also use one little drum hit or a piece of a horn or something like that. Yes he did take these things from a copyrighted recording, but it may not really be enough to warrant reaction from the original artist.
All of these considerations make for a very controversial argument about Girl Talk's case. Hopefully, for the sake of his fan base, there won't be any prosecution of his work for copyrights. While his work isn't as relevant now as it used to be, he does have 5 albums out that haven't been touched. I suppose we will have to see in the future.
It would be interesting to see how any law suits against Girl Talk would play out, and if the Fair and Transformative Use laws would be upheld. I do think that he is protected under these laws, since he is creating a new song from bits and pieces of other songs, much like the video used bits and pieces of Disney movies to explain the Fair Use laws. I also think most of these law suits stem from financial greed. I think the corporations that own the music are upset that their music is being used and they are not profiting. But how much of sound from a certain instrument can you really copyright?
ReplyDelete